Richard S. Barnett
ARMAGEDDON ADDENDUM

Did Pharaoh Sheshonq I Attack Jerusalem?”
The answer to the title question in Yigal Levin’s feature article in BIBLICAL ARCHEOLOGY REVIEW (July/August 2012, 38-4: 42-52, 66) is No—King Rehoboam of Judah bought him off when he and his forces reached at Gibeon in 925 BC.
The Bible records Sheshonq’s campaign during the fifth year of Rehoboam’s reign in 1 Kings 14:25-28 and 2 Chronicles 12:2-9. 2 Chronicles numbers his combined forces at “twelve hundred chariots and sixty thousand horsemen and the innumerable troops of Libyans, Sukkites and Cushites that came with him from Egypt” (verse 3). “Shishak” is the biblical form of his name.
Analysis of Sheshonq’s victory inscriptions on the right of the Bubastite Portal, the monumental entry to a forecourt that Sheshonq added to the temple of Amun-Re in Karnak, has identified eleven rows of relief carvings of tiny, bound prisoners holding name rings, each with the name of a city or town. A hundred of at least 150 name rings are still legible, and their grouping enabled Levin to unravel their order of conquest. Sheshonq, with uncharacteristic diffidence, omitted the name of Jerusalem.
His campaign culminated at Megiddo, however, after receiving Rehoboam’s tribute—the royal and Temple treasures of Jerusalem. Sheshonq and his army marched north from Gibeon, through the central highlands to Schechem and Tirzah in the kingdom of Israel, down into the Jordan valley, and north again to Rehov and Beth Shan. From there, the Egyptians criss-crossed the plains of Jezreel and Esdraelon as far west as Megiddo.
Sheshonq left a ten-ft tall victory stele at Megiddo and returned to Egypt by the coastal road, the biblical “Way of the Sea.” Archeological excavations at Megiddo in the early 1930s recovered a chunk of Sheshonq’s monument with his name inscribed.
Sheshonq’s victory portal includes a flowery speech of congratulations from Amun-Re but no accounts of his battles in Judah and Israel. The biblical tally of the tribute paid by Rehoboam leaves no doubt that he paid a huge price to escape his “Armageddon.” Other parts of Judah and Israel did not escape so easily.

ARMAGEDDON AND THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE

Part Two

The 1918 Battle of Armageddon was one of the last big battles of World War I and a cataclysmic defeat for the Ottoman Empire, which collapsed soon after. While not one of the greatest battles in history, the British victory revived morale by invoking the name of Armageddon, sealed the fate of the Ottoman Empire, and introduced tactics that would be refined in World War II.

For the British Army, the Armageddon campaign was one of its better-managed efforts, in contrast to the fiasco of its encounter with the Ottomans at Gallipoli in 1915.  The Turks responded to Gallipoli with an attack on the Suez Canal, which the British easily brushed off. Their Egyptian Expeditionary Force pursued the Ottoman army through Sinai into Palestine, but soon ground to a halt in the face of superior numbers. Revolts against the Ottomans broke out in Arabia in 1916, but lightly armed Hejaz tribesmen were unable to dislodge them from Medina. The Turks, however, controlled the railroad linking Damascus to Medina and used it to reinforce and supply their troops in Palestine and Arabia.

In October 1916, the British sent a senior officer to investigate the revolt, accompanied by T.E. Lawrence, a junior intelligence officer, in hope of taking advantage of the revolution behind Turkish lines. Seeing the importance of the railroad, Lawrence, the famous Lawrence of Arabia, established a rapport with their leader and enlisted the Hejaz Arabs to harass the Turks. As they moved north into Palestine, the Hejaz Arabs and Lawrence won over Transjordanian Arabs to their cause. The Arab forces defeated an Ottoman battalion in July 1917 and occupied their port of Aqaba.

The British General Edmund Allenby took command of the stalled Egyptian Expeditionary Force in June, 1917. He supplied the united Arabs with guns, ammunition and gold and sent small contingents of British, French and Indian troops to Aqaba to support them. As more and more Arabs rallied to support the revolt, including Arab units in the Ottoman Army, Allenby took the offensive, freeing Jerusalem from Ottoman control on December 9, 1917.

Allenby began laying plans for a massive campaign to crush the Ottoman forces, which included three armies of 34,000 men commanded by German officers, who threatened to retake Jerusalem. Allenby distracted them by using Arab guerillas. In January 1918, Lawrence led an Arab attack on Tafila that wiped out another Turkish battalion. Allenby, however, had to wait until August for reinforcements before launching his attack. Allenby applied tactical lessons learned in battle with the Germans in France to coordinate his multinational force of 35,000 infantry, cavalry and artillery supported by airplanes. In preparation, he asked T. E. Lawrence to lead the Arab forces in a diversionary attack on a strategic railroad junction at Deraa on September 17 while he moved his forces. British aircraft strafed Deraa the day before the Arab attack, diverting the Al-Afuleh reserves to Deraa.

Allenby’s cavalry secured the Megiddo pass and other passes through the Carmel range before entering the Jezreel Valley and capturing the communication centers at Al-Afuleh and Beisan. The British overwhelmed the overstretched Ottomans cut off in the Esdraelon Valley. Allenby directed his cavalry through a gap in their front while his infantry widened the gap. The Ottomans had no reserves, allowing Allenby’s cavalry to take all their objectives. His attacks shattered that Ottoman army and its commander fled.

Outflanked in the Nablus area, the next Ottoman army retreated east from Nablus through the Wadi Fara and into the Jordan Valley during the night of September 20 and 21, with British forces close behind. British aircraft spotted the column the next morning as it passed through a gorge to the east of Nablus. The British aerial assault disabled many of the Ottoman vehicles and blocked the gorge. Under continuous air attack, Turkish survivors abandoned their equipment and ran north to be captured in the Jezreel Valley by Allenby’s waiting forces.

The last Ottoman army, now isolated east of the Jordan, retreated north in disorder from Amman on September 22, harried by British aircraft and Arab forces. Their German commander attempted to form a defensive line along the Jordan and Yarmuk Rivers but British cavalry broke through it on September 26. Allenby’s Anzac Mounted Division occupied Amman the same day.

Cooperating with the Arab army, Allenby’s troops won several clashes during their march to Damacus, which the Arabs took on October 1. Along the coast, British forces advancing along the Mediterranean captured Beirut seven days later. Allenby directed his units north against slight Turkish resistance, and Aleppo fell to his cavalry and the Arabs on October 25. The Ottomans made peace on October 30 by signing the Armistice of Mudros.

Allenby’s forces lost 782 killed, 4,179 wounded, and 382 missing during the Battle of Megiddo. Estimates of Ottoman losses are uncertain. Over 25,000 men were captured and fewer than 10,000 escaped during the retreat north.

ARMAGEDDON AND THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE

Part One

The Ottoman Empire (1299-1922) was a Turkish Empire that surpassed all its predecessors in southeast Asia, eastern Europe and North Africa at its greatest extent. Originating in eastern Turkey during the decline of the Byzantine Empire and following the collapse of the Mongol Empire, it surpassed all its predecessors in power and duration.

The battlefield fell into Ottoman hands in 1516 during the reign of Selim I. After defeating the Safiyid dynasty in Persia after they incited rebellion among Turcoman tribes in eastern Anatolia, Selim turned his attention south to the Mamluk Empire, centered in Cairo, that controlled the holy places if Islam and Christendom. The Mamluks had expanded their rule into Palestine and Syria after the defeat of the Mongols at Ain Jalut in 1260.

By 1516, the Mamluk Sultanate had decayed so far that its army was no match for the disciplined Ottoman cavalry, infantry and artillery. They swept through the valleys of Jezreel and Esdraelon, the battleground named Armageddon, without effective opposition. The populations of Syria and Egypt welcomed the Ottomans as a relief from corruption and turbulence under the Mamluks. Many ejected their Mamluk garrisons, while Mamluk officials elsewhere betrayed their overlords in return for new positions under Ottoman rule. Damascus and Aleppo fell to Selim in 1516 and Cairo in 1517.

The Empire’s decline, however, lasted longer than its growth, and the Empire met its Armageddon on the ancient battlefield in 1918.

HULAGU KHAN MEETS HIS ARMAGEDDON

Hulagu Khan (1217-1265), a grandson of the Mongol emperor Ghengis Khan and brother of Mongke Khan, Kublai Khan and Arik Boke, expanded the Mongol east into southeast Asia before his defeat at the ancient battleground of Armageddon in Palestine.

Hulagu began his campaign while his brother Mongke was Great Khan. Mongke conceived a strategic plan in 1255 to conquer all the remnants of the Moslem empire at least as far as Egypt. He equipped Hulagu with a fifth of all the Mongol warriors, supported by engineers other auxiliaries, and commissioned him to destroy every Moslem state in his path that did not submit.

Hulagu’s army easily overwhelmed the Moslem rulers of southern Iran and laid siege to the Caliphate of Baghdad in 1258 after destroying most of the caliph’s army late in 1257. The Mongols destroyed Baghdad after its surrender and marched on to Syria in1259, conquering the Ayyubid rulers of Damascus in 1260 with the aid of the last Crusader principalities in southern Syria.

Cairo under the Bahri Mamluks remained as the last seat of Moslem power. Hulagu turned south through Palestine with the intention of invading Egypt. Hulagu abandoned his plan at this point when he received news of his brother’s death. He returned to Karakorum to claim his place as Great Khan, leaving only a relatively small force of Mongols to complete the occupation of Palestine. They occupied Gaza and Ashkelon, but the Mamluks did not remain idle.

Instead, the Mamluk sultan Kutuz made a deal with the Crusaders to secure peaceful passage of their forces through Palestine, where they met the Mongol cavalry in the Valley of Jezreel at Ain Jalut, the biblical Spring of Harod below Mount Gilboa, on September 3, 1260. Each side fielded about 20,000 troops. The Mamluk split their forces to lure the Mongols into an ambush in the highlands. After fierce combat, the Mamluk heavy cavalry won a decisive victory over the Mongol cavalry, with the aid of primitive hand cannon, and executed their general, Kitbuqa.

Ain Jalut, on the battleground of Armageddon, marked the reversal of the Mongol armies, hitherto invincible. Hulagu lost control of Syria and the boundary of the Mongol Empire receded to the Tigris River despite repeated Hulagu’s attempts to reconquer Syria. The battle of Ain Jalut thereby ended the Mongol threat to Europe.

Note: Although Ain Jalut means “Goliath’s Well” in Arabic, the Arabic tradition is mistaken. Ain Jalut has nothing to do with the duel between David and Goliath, which took place in the Valley of Elah in Judah.

ARMAGEDDON AND THE DAY OF BEISAN

The great Arab victory in the battle of Yarmuk (August, 634) did not immediately give them possession of western Palestine.

The remnants of the Byzantine army withdrew west, across the Jordan to the ancient city of Beth-Shan, known as Scythopolis under Roman rule. Beth-Shan occupies a strong defensive position on the crest of basalt flows at the foot of the Gilboa range. The east side, overlooking the Jordan, forms a three hundred-foot basalt cliff cut by narrow ravines. The Byzantines fortified the cliff and the north face of the city, and they diverted water flowing from Ain Jalud into the marshy lowlands of the Jordan valley north of Beth-Shan at the east end of the Vale of Esdraelon.

The Arab army settled down on the east bank of the Jordan to wait for summer to dry out the marshes. The Byzantines, however, chose not to wait for summer but to surprise the Arabs on their own ground. Their impatience got the better of them, and the Arabs inflicted a second defeat on the Byzantines outside the fortress of Pella in February, 635. The Byzantines abandoned Pella and Beth-Shan, leaving their inhabitants to surrender. The Moslem calendar commemorates the surrender as the Day of Beisan because it secured their control of the roads to Damascus and western Palestine.

Damascus fell to the Arabs in August or September 635. The Byzantine Emperor Heraclius raised a new army in 636 and sent it to reclaim Syria. The Arab forces annihilated it in a second battle at Yarmuk. They then completed their occupation of the Judean highlands in 638 by negotiating the surrender of Jerusalem. The Day of Beisan thus entered Moslem history as the equivalent of the Day of Armageddon.

The Arab Conquests and Armageddon

The Byzantine Empire inherited the province of Palestine after the division of the Roman Empire in 330AD. Eastern Christianity flourished there and the ancient battlefield of Armageddon lay quiet until the Seventh Century. Thirty years of warfare between the Byzantine and Persian Empires weakened both, allowing a new force, Islam, to emerge in Arabia, consolidate itself, and challenge both empires.
Persian forces under King Chosroes II invaded Syria early in the Seventh Century, bent on avenging recent defeats. Jews in Palestine and Syria rallied to the Persians, and a strong contingent joined the Persian division that marched south across the Plain of Esdraelon to attack the Byzantine stronghold at Jerusalem. Joined by Arabs and more Jews from southern Palestine, the combined force stormed Jerusalem amid great slaughter in July 614. Persians and Jews then ravaged Christian cities and buildings throughout the rest of Palestine, including Esdraelon.
The Jews hoped that the Persians would allow them to form a new commonwealth, but Chosroes merely raised their taxes until the return of the Byzantines after fourteen years. They did not stay long.
The year 570 saw the birth of Mohammed, the future Prophet of Islam, at Mecca. The house of his birth lay within half a mile of the Kaaba, an ancient shrine. Mohammed’s revered grandfather successfully defended the Kaaba from an Abyssinian attempt to destroy it in 570. Mohammed had a vision of the archangel Gabriel in 610 that changed his life. He began preaching three years later, but made slow progress until 620, when he began preaching to pilgrims to the Kaaba. By 622, seventy pilgrim converts pledged their support. From their refuge in Medina, the new Muslims began raiding the countryside, at first to support themselves, and then to make converts. They consolidated their control of the Arabian peninsula by in 630 by occupying Mecca and making the Kaaba the destination of annual pilgrimages.
Mohammed next turned his attention to the Byzantine Empire and led a bloodless expedition to Tebook that resulted in neighboring rulers making peace and paying tribute. He gave orders for a second expedition in 632, but died that June. A year of turbulence followed until Mohammed’s elected successor Abu Bekr reunited Arabia under his rule and resumed Mohammed’s policy of expansion. Within fifty years, the Arab Empire and Islam extended from the Atlas Mountains of North Africa to the Indus River of India.
Jerusalem surrendered to the Arabs during the winter of 637-638, following their victory over the Byzantines at Yarmouk in 636. This great victory won access to the Jordan Valley, the great Vale of Esdraelon, and control of all the routes south to Jerusalem. For the Byzantines, the Arab victory at Yarmouk was a disaster that led to the loss of their empire—an “Armageddon.”

HANDEL AND ARMAGEDDON

What is the connection between Handel and Armageddon?

George Frederick Handel never went near that ancient battleground. He did, however compose an oratorio about Judas Maccabeus (1748), the hero of the Jewish revolt against the Seleucid kings of Syria, heirs to a portion of Alexander the Great’s empire. The Seleucids murdered Judas near Beth Shan, at the southeastern end of the ancient battleground.

The most famous chorus from Judas Maccabaeus is “See, the Conqu’ring Hero Comes!” It’s a grand tune and still beloved in England. It’s such a grand tune that “The Conqu’ring Hero” fits it as well as a wagon hitched to a racehorse.

The Swiss hymn writer Edmond Louis Budry (1854-1932) noticed the disparity long before me and borrowed Handel’s chorus for his Easter hymn, “À toi la gloire, O Ressuscité!” Richard Birch Hoyle (1875–19390 translated the hymn into English in 1923 as “Thine is the Glory.”

Thine is the glory, risen, conqu’ring Son;
Endless is the victory, Thou o’er death hast won;
Angels in bright raiment rolled the stone away,
Kept the folded grave clothes where Thy body lay.

Refrain
Thine is the glory, risen conqu’ring Son,
Endless is the vict’ry, Thou o’er death hast won.

Lo! Jesus meets us, risen from the tomb;
Lovingly He greets us, scatters fear and gloom;
Let the church with gladness, hymns of triumph sing;
For her Lord now liveth, death hath lost its sting.

Refrain

No more we doubt Thee, glorious Prince of life;
Life is naught without Thee; aid us in our strife;
Make us more than conqu’rors, through Thy deathless love:
Bring us safe through Jordan to Thy home above.

Refrain

It’s safe to say that “Thine is the Glory” fits Handel’s chorus better than the original words. After all, did not Jesus Christ win a greater victory at Gologotha than Judas Maccabeus ever did. And is he not the ultimate victor in the apocalyptic battle against evil at Armageddon?

To quote from another oratorio by Handel, “The Lord God Omnipotent reigneth!”

WHERE IS HE?

Where is He, born in a stable,
Laid in a manger cut from rock?
Grown in grace, He walked among us,
                Preaching a kingdom built on rock.

Where is He who walked among us,
Preaching a kingdom built on rock?
           They took Him, tried Him, and flogged Him,
           Nailed Him to a cross set high on rock.

Where is He whom they took from us,
Nailed Him to a cross set high on rock?
            We took Him down before nightfall,
           Borrowed a tomb dug deep in rock.

Where is He who suffered for us?
Lying in a tomb hewn from rock?
Death could not keep Him from us:
              Risen, He lives and reigns: our Rock!

* * *

Jesus and #Armageddon

Jesus and the Widow of Nain
We don’t habitually associate the life of Jesus with Armageddon, the Greek name given to the Plain of Esdraelon that is the scene of the apocalyptic battle and final overthrow of evil in Revelation. 16:16.
Nazareth actually sits in a range of hills bounding the north side of Esdraelon, which is not a single plain but several separated by low ridges. Jezreel occupied one, and Nain and Shunem lay two miles away (as the crow flies) on the north and south flanks of another, the Hill of Moreh, which is separated by a four-mile wide valley from Mt. Tabor. Part of the Philistine army camped there when they came to fight King Saul at Mt. Gilboa, on the south side of the valley of Jezreel. Shunem was the home of Elisha’s patroness, whose son he brought back to life (2 Kings 4:8-37).
The hills of Lower Galilee bound the northeast side of Esdraelon, and Nazareth lies about six miles northwest (as the crow flies) on the north face of one of these hills. To approach Lake Galilee ( about 15 miles east of Nazareth, Jesus would normally follow the trail down the Turan Valley. His visit to Nain (Luke 7:11-17) follows his first circuit of the west side of the lake, ending at Capernaum (Luke 7:1-10).
Luke does not explain Jesus’ itinerary or reasons for visiting Nain during a funeral procession. Luke says, simply,

 As he approached the town gate, a dead person was being carried out—the only son of his mother, and she was a widow. And a large crowd from the town was with her. When the Lord saw her, his heart went out to her and he said, “Don’t cry” (verses 12-13).

As we near the end of this Holy Week, Jesus’ concern for the widow appears prophetic. He did not wait to be asked to intervene. He immediately comforted the widow and revived her son with a command.
We can imagine that Jesus thought of his own mother, now widowed and soon to lose him. He knew about the plight of widows in those days—destitution threatened them if they lacked sons. Jesus did not always do as his mother wished, but he did not disappoint her at the wedding in Cana or in the hour of his own death. Just as he provided wine for the wedding, so he appointed a guardian for his mother.
Luke’s brief account of Jesus’ skirmish with death in a corner of the historic battlefield of Armageddon bears a lesson for the end of this solemn Holy Week. His Kingdom, which is not of this world, will disappoint our worldly expectations. Nevertheless, he is the steadfast hope who will not disappoint us, leave us, or forsake us.

Great is the mystery of faith:
Christ has died;
Christ has risen;
Christ will come again!

Armageddon and the First Jewish War

The First Jewish War, which culminated in the destruction of Jerusalem and its Temple in 70 AD, began as a case of civil unrest–nothing new during Roman rule. This time turbulence got so out of hand that all Judea fell into a state of lawlessness that threatened to spread to Egypt. When the Roman governor Florus left Jerusalem in 66 AD, a mob captured the Antonia fortress. Other rebels stormed Roman outposts, including a garrison at Mt. Tabor and Herod the Great’s fortress at Masada, overlooking the Dead Sea. The Roman governor of Syria, Cestius had to intervene in order to protect Roman interests and collect taxes.

Cestius himself was ineffective and his troops were more trained for war than peace-keeping and police duties. The 12th Legion’s tactics, moreover, were ill-adapted for guerilla warfare. Cestius botched his assault on Jerusalem and Jewish guerillas mauled his legion to pieces during their retreat.

Cestius’s failure gave the Jews time to organize their resistance, and they set up military districts thoughout Judea. They consolidated their defenses by the time Nero appointed his best general, Vespasian, to take command. Vespasian took his time to assemble three legions at Ptolemais before marching inland. He deployed screeens of lightly armed auxiliaries to clean out ambushes ahead of his advance guard and the legions. A rear guard of cavalry and infantry prevented guarilla attacks from the rear.  Vespasian proceeded systematically across Galilee.

While laying siege to Gamala on the east side of Lake Kinnereth (Galilee), Vespasian dispatched a cavalry detachment of 600 up the Vale of Esdraelon to scout the situation at Mt. Tabor, which rises above the southeast  end of the ancient battleground of Armageddon. It’s plainly visible across the valley of Esdraelon from Mount Carmel. A larger force of Jewish rebels occupying the Roman fort on Mt. Tabor prepared for battle. Placidus, the Roman commander, invited the rebels to meet him and make a truce that would spare their lives.

The rebels answered by pouring downhill to attack the Romans. Placidus feigned a retreat and drew the rebels out into the open plain, where his counter-attack cut off the rebels’ retreat and slaughtered those who did not surrender. The rebels had forgotten the example of Deborah and Barak when they defended Mt. Tabor from Sisera’s army and waited for Sisera’s vaunted charioteers to get mired in the muddy valley before attacking.

Jewish rebels did not give up elsewhere in Judea. The Romans needed another three years to subdue Jerusalem and three more to capture Masada. The defeat of the Jewish rebels at Mt. Tabor was therefore by no means their #Armageddon, but it was a part of the beginning of the beginning of the fall of Jerusalem. Secure in their control of the valleys of Jezreel and Esdraelon, the Roman war machine advanced on Jerusalem from the north by the highland route.

NOTE

The existence of the Roman fort on Mt. Tabor, confirmed by archeology, makes it unlikely that it was the Mount of Transfiguration, as claimed by some traditions. The geographic background details in Mark’s gospel make it much more likely that the Transfiguration of Jesus occured on Mount Hermon.